Field marshal haig hero or butcher

Middle powers and their strategic relationships - David Leece Institute Proceedings Countering violent extremism in Australia - Julian Droogan Low technology, high impact violent extremist events are on the rise around the world.

Field marshal haig hero or butcher

Field marshal haig hero or butcher

A large number of historians subscribe to this theory and savagely attack Haig as being responsible for a wholesale premeditated slaughter, however some historians are selective in their research often quoting from publications holding a certain bias.

I have examined the facts and statistics and reached an interesting conclusion that I have to admit is my own personal opinion, I would like to hear from students their thoughts on my calculated opinion and I would hope that it could possibly assist them in their studies.

Field marshal haig hero or butcher

John French had presided over the B. F in an ineffective campaign on the Western Front. Haig was very much aware of the strengths of the enemy, the formidable Imperial German Army and as a result adopted controversial and extremely agressive tactics against them. The German Army was superior in equipment, tactical prowess of modern warfare and command structure than either the British or French armies.

Haig knew this and maintained his stance of attack throughout the campaign. Haig never allowed the Germans to launch major offensives as he knew that defeat would have been the result.

The Germans were masters of the defensive role, many historians have suggested that the Allies should have adopted similar tactics and consolidated their positions, disaster would have ensued. The Germans would have picked off the French in marauding attacks before smashing their lines.

The French would have panicked and bolted to defend their capital, Paris. The British, including their new armies, colonial and empire troops would have been bulged into a pocket towards the north of the front to access channel ports, surrounded and defeated.

Even if successes were made and the Germans driven back in places their massively superior defensive positions would have been intact and they would have repelled the Allies on open ground, all of that would have resulted in even higher casualties.

Fictional examples used ironically

King George V would have had to sue for a peace with Kaiser Wilhelm, this would have been achieved. Europe would have been merely a series of German satellites, and Britain would have been reliant economically on Germany.

There is one outstanding point to make. If Haig was a butcher then why did the French who mobilised fewer men suffer far more casualties.

The Germans who mobilised more but not significantly more suffered almost double the casualties of the British.

Battle of the Somme - Wikipedia

The poppies of rememberance Sunday bore his name on the petal. At the unveiling of his statue in on Whitehall, overveterens marched past in salute to a man who as he openly admitted in the publication of his diaries was far from perfect, but who had the strength of character to administer decisions that no ordinary man could ever make.This article possibly contains original research.

Please improve it by verifying the claims made and adding inline initiativeblog.coments consisting only of original research should be removed. (July ) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) (Learn how .

Douglas Haig – butcher or hero? By Rupert Colley

The Battle of the Somme (French: Bataille de la Somme; German: Schlacht an der Somme), also known as the Somme Offensive, was a battle of the First World War fought by the armies of the British Empire and French Empire against the German took place between 1 July and 18 November on both sides of the upper reaches of the River Somme in France.

Militaria Mart features a reputable dealer directory and resource site for collectors of militaria. is the leading provider of online obituaries for the newspaper industry. enhances online obituaries with Guest Books, funeral home information, and florist links.

Field Marshal Haig: “Hero or Butcher of the Somme” I consider the field marshal as a butcher and a hero for numerous reasons.

While the insinuation of Haig as a butcher ignores many positives that he possessed, the implication of him being a hero also neglects negatives that the field marshal obtains. Fullmetal Alchemist has a serial killer named Barry whose actual job is that of a butcher.

When introducing himself to Al at one point, he notes one of his nicknames was "Barry the Butcher", but adds that he much preferred the name he usually goes by: Barry the Chopper.

Was Field-Marshal Haig a hero or dunderhead? - Telegraph